FrankBlog

Employee Retention: Understanding What Keeps Your Team

Written by David Peasall, VP, Human Resources | Oct 23, 2026, 4:00:00 AM

Employee retention is an employer's ability to keep its employees over time. Although it’s measurable, the number alone doesn’t tell the full story.

Every owner has felt the sting of a good employee giving two weeks' notice and wondering what they missed. Whether people stay isn’t usually based on a single perk, but the sum of their daily experiences—how their manager treats them, whether the workload is fair, whether they feel noticed, and if they can see a future.

That's good news for small and mid-sized business owners because those factors are visible, and you can change them even without a large HR department.

This guide covers what drives employee retention, why people leave, how to measure it, and how to improve it, with practical steps a small business can start this month.

What Is Employee Retention?

Employee retention is an organization's ability to keep its employees over a given period. It’s measured as a percentage, known as the retention rate, the rate at which people stay. It also describes the ongoing work an employer does to give people reasons to stay.

Retention has a mirror image called turnover, which describes employees leaving an organization and being replaced. According to the Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM), turnover is the rate at which people leave an organization. Turnover counts every separation, whether voluntary (the employee resigns) or involuntary (the employer ends the employment, such as through a layoff).

It’s the employer's responsibility to monitor and influence retention, as it’s a strong indicator of overall workforce stability.

Before getting into what shapes employee experiences that drive retention, it helps to see what's at stake when people leave.

Why Is Employee Retention Important?

Employee retention matters because every departure carries costs that never appear on an invoice. Gallup's 2019 analysis puts the cost of replacing an employee at one-half to two times that person's annual salary.

The costs associated with recruiting, onboarding, and training are real. For a $50,000 role, that's $25,000 to $100,000. The range is an estimate, and the actual number depends on the role, how long the job stays open, and how long a new hire needs to reach full speed.

Other challenges related to departures are harder to quantify, such as the loss of knowledge and relationships. The service manager who knows which customers need a call before an invoice goes out can't be replaced. Stable teams deliver more consistent service because customers see familiar faces and handoffs run more smoothly.

Another consideration is that the work remains even when the employee departs. It simply falls on others who take on extra tasks while the job stays open, which can put the next person at risk of burnout. Nationally, Gallup estimates that voluntary turnover costs U.S. businesses about $1 trillion every year.

So, what actually influences someone's decision to stay? The next section breaks it down.

What Drives Employee Retention?

Employee retention is shaped by six things employees feel every week: pay and benefits, their manager, room to grow, their workload, recognition, and the work itself.

 

 

Competitive Compensation and Benefits

Competitive compensation and benefits mean employees believe their pay is fair for the work and the local market, and that their benefits fit their lives. It shows up in small moments, like whether someone can afford the health plan premium.

Gallup found that 53% of U.S. employees in 2025 called better pay or benefits very important in their next job.

Picture a dental office that loses a hygienist after she learns a competitor offers paid time off (PTO) and a retirement match that her employer doesn't. The benefits gap decided it.

Supportive Managers and Clear Expectations

Supportive managers provide mentorship to their employees, actively help them grow in their profession, set clear expectations, give regular feedback, treat people fairly, act with integrity, and stay available when something goes wrong. Employees judge this with simple questions. Do I know what's expected of me? Can I raise a problem safely?

Gallup reports that only 49% of U.S. employees say they know what is expected of them (May 2026), and that managers account for at least 70% of the variance in team engagement. About half the workforce is guessing at the job, and the manager is closest to the answer.

Consider a field supervisor who reassigns crews every morning without explanation. People stop planning, and the strongest start watching job postings. Outside HR guidance can help with performance conversations and manager training.

Career Growth and Development

Career growth is about more than waiting for a promotion. A 20-person business may have no next title to offer, but there's almost always a next skill or project. Building new competencies, working with mentors, and taking on meaningful responsibilities can provide employees with avenues for the advancement and development they desire.

According to Gallup, 31% of U.S. employees say someone at work encourages their development, and 32% had learning opportunities in the past year (May 2026). Roughly two in three aren't reporting either, so modest investment stands out.

Examples of modest investments can include pairing a new coordinator with the bookkeeper for a month or formalizing upskilling programs.

FrankCrum clients can extend their development pathways with TrainingHub, its learning management system (LMS), to offer online coursework in compliance, business, and leadership skills, and more.

Work-Life Balance and Manageable Workloads

Employees are willing to trade time for pay, but they also need time for their own pursuits. Work-life balance means an employee's schedule, workload, and time off leave room for life outside work. To provide a manageable workload, employers must ensure that the amount of work matches the number of people doing it.

Gallup found that 60% of U.S. employees in 2025 named greater work-life balance and better personal well-being as very important in a next job, ahead of pay or benefits (53%).

Of course, flexibility varies by role. While a receptionist can't work from home, they can get a schedule posted two weeks ahead and a fair way to swap shifts.

If you are considering changes to schedules or pay, be sure to check applicable rules. The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), the federal wage-and-hour law, sets overtime requirements, and many states add rules on breaks and leave. Confirm what applies with an HR expert or your state labor agency before making any moves.

Recognition and a Sense of Belonging

Recognition and belonging are basic human needs, so it’s unsurprising that they show up in the workplace. Recognition means employees hear that their work was noticed and mattered. Belonging means they feel respected and included. When those needs go unmet, work becomes transactional, and people have little reason to stay at a job.

Gallup reports that only 29% of U.S. employees received recognition or praise in the past seven days, and 40% say someone at work seems to care about them as a person (May 2026). That's a low bar, so small, consistent efforts stand out.

Recognition needs specifics, not a budget. A manager who tells a delivery driver that the early arrival saved a customer's event does more than a generic thank-you email. A new hire left out of the group chat will notice within a week.

Meaningful Work and Autonomy

Most people spend a large share of their waking hours working. When they can see how their job affects customers, coworkers, or the business, the effort feels worthwhile. Meaningful work means employees understand how their job connects to the big picture.

Autonomy signals trust. Being allowed to make decisions within a role tells employees that their employer believes they’re capable. It also makes the work more engaging, because problem-solving is more interesting than following orders.

Gallup's data shows that only 26% of U.S. employees feel their opinions count, and 34% get to do what they do best every day (May 2026).

A service technician who can approve repairs up to a set dollar amount feels trusted. One who must call the owner about every $40 part does not.

These drivers don't operate in isolation, which is why the reasons people leave are usually more tangled than a single line on an exit form.

Why Do Employees Leave?

Employees leave when the gap between what they need and what they get stays open too long. It’s rarely one event, and it’s rarely only about money.

Many owners assume people usually leave for more pay. In 2024, pay and benefits were the most common single reason U.S. employees left, but they were cited only 16% of the time. Grouped by theme, engagement and culture (37%) and well-being and work-life balance (31%) accounted for 68% of exits.

That means a raise may not fix a problem that lives in an employee’s daily experience. Problems like those tend to build quietly. Gallup’s 2019 research found that 52% of employees who voluntarily left said their manager or organization could have done something to prevent their departure.

Gallup also found that 51% said no one discussed their job satisfaction or future in the three months before they left. Most exits, in other words, come with warning signs nobody asked about.

Some concerns start even before the first day. People sometimes leave within weeks because the job differs from the one described, and a role advertised as flexible that turns out to be rigid damages trust early.

Not every departure is a workplace problem, though. People relocate, care for families, return to school, retire, or face health issues. Sorting exits into those you could have influenced and those you couldn’t can keep you from chasing problems that aren’t there.

At the end of the day, employers must examine retention in the context of their own organizations and continuously measure it.

How to Measure Employee Retention

The employee retention rate is the percentage of employees who stay with your organization through a set period. The formula looks like this:

Retention rate = (employees at the end of the period who were also employed at the start ÷ employees at the start) × 100

Say you start the year with 40 employees, and 34 of those same people are still there on December 31. That's 34 ÷ 40 = 0.85, or an 85% retention rate. Employees hired during the year aren't counted, so track new-hire retention separately.

The timeframe matters. SHRM notes that retention is often calculated annually, but narrower periods and specific worker groups can be tracked to uncover better insights. An annual figure can hide a rough first 90 days, and seasonal businesses should compare the same quarter year over year.

An overall rate can also hide where the problem sits. Review results in a few ways:

    • By department or location
    • By manager
    • By tenure band, such as under 90 days, under one year, and one to three years

A company-wide 85% might include one location at 60%. Numbers show where people leave, not why, so pair them with employee feedback and exit interviews, which are conversations or surveys with employees who are leaving.

For outside context, the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics tracks quits through its Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey (JOLTS), which is based on employer reports.

Does High Employee Retention Mean Employees Are Engaged?

No. Employee engagement describes how involved and enthusiastic employees are in their work and workplace. Retention only records whether they're still there.

A retention number can't say why someone stays. Some employees are committed. Others may stay for reasons unrelated to how they feel about the work, and a rate can't separate the two.

Only 31% of U.S. employees were engaged at work in 2025, per Gallup, and engaged employees are 47% less likely to be job hunting.

Look Beyond the Retention Rate Checklist

Before you decide your retention numbers are healthy, ask:

    • Employee feedback: When did we last ask employees what's working and what isn't? What did we do with the answers?
    • Workload: Are the same people regularly covering gaps, working extra hours, or skipping time off?
    • Growth opportunities: Has each employee had a development conversation or learning opportunity this year?
    • Management support: Do employees know what's expected of them, and do they get feedback they can use?

With measurement and context in place, you can start acting on what you learn.

How to Improve Employee Retention

Improving employee retention works best as a short, repeatable cycle rather than a one-time program. Five steps cover it.



    • Identify where turnover is happening. Look for clusters, such as one location, supervisor, or stage of the first year.
    • Ask employees what supports or undermines their decision to stay. A stay interview is a one-on-one conversation with a current employee about what keeps them and what might push them out. SHRM describes trained managers asking why employees stay and what would help them stay longer. Short surveys work too. Ask only what you're prepared to act on.
    • Prioritize the issues within your control. Sort what you hear into what's fixable now, what's fixable with time or budget, and what's outside your control. Start with fast fixes, and don't promise what you can't deliver.
    • Assign responsibility and communicate changes. Give each action a named owner and a date. Then tell employees what you heard and what you're doing, even if the answer on one item is "not this year."
    • Review results and follow up. Re-measure retention for the affected group and check back with the same employees after 90 days. If nothing has moved, return to step two.

Before changing pay, benefits, schedules, leave, or policies, confirm federal, state, and local requirements with an HR expert or regulatory agency.

Doing this well takes time and know-how, and that's where outside support can help.

How FrankCrum Can Help Employee Retention

Understanding what keeps your team comes down to listening to employees and acting on what you learn. Most owners don't have the hours for that.

FrankCrum, a professional employer organization (PEO) that shares HR, payroll, and benefits responsibilities with employers, gives clients a dedicated HRCI- or SHRM-SCP-certified HR consultant through FrankAdvice. That team can help with performance conversations, manager development, employee handbooks, and policy questions, so retention work doesn't fall to the owner alone.

Learn more about FrankCrum's HR management services.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is employee retention?

Employee retention is an employer's ability to keep its employees over time. It's usually measured as a retention rate, the percentage of employees who stay through a set period, and it also describes the efforts that give people reasons to stay. Retention is the flip side of turnover, which counts the people who leave.

What are the 3 R's of employee retention?

The 3 R's are a commonly cited framework, and versions vary. One widely used version names Respect, Recognition, and Reward: treat people with respect, acknowledge good work, and reward contributions fairly. Some sources swap in other terms, such as Recruiting or Reskilling. Treat it as a practical checklist, not a research-based standard.

What are the 5 C's of retention?

The 5 C's are another informal framework. One common version lists Communication, Connection, Culture, Contribution, and Career Development. Each works as a prompt: Do employees get clear information, feel connected to coworkers, trust the culture, see how they contribute, and have room to grow? Other sources list different C's, so use it as a conversation starter.

What is considered good employee retention?

There's no single good number. Retention varies by industry, role, location, and business size, so compare yourself to your own past results first, then to industry data. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics publishes national quit and separation rates in its JOLTS reports, which provide useful context but not a target.

Who is responsible for employee retention?

Everyone plays a part, but owners and senior leaders set the tone. Managers have the most day-to-day influence, since Gallup finds they account for at least 70% of the variance in team engagement. HR or an HR partner supplies measurement, policies, and guidance.

What are the signs of low employee retention?

Common signs include rising resignations, short average tenure, repeated turnover in the same role or under the same manager, and heavy turnover in the first 90 days. Other signals include falling participation in surveys and meetings and exit interview themes that repeat.